I am on the lookout for a Powerline Spirit of Progress VRS Buffet Car.
Thanks in advance,
Rob
Sorry if this is a bit off topic. I'm new, well back to collecting models (since I sold my Hornby layout in 1976) and I'm amazed at the great and detailed locos available out there. I'm looking to get a streamlined S class steam and done a bit of research, but the prices, and presumably quality, varies greatly. Could someone comment on the difference between, say, the Steam Era Models metal kit at $595 and the BGM version at $1,950. The latter is fully built, so I would expect it to be a little more expensive but that's a huge difference. Then there's an unstreamlined BGM version on Ebay for $3,245, second hand, yet a new X class BGM is $1,950. So all a bit confusing. I guess what I really want to know is, which are the best?
Sorry if this is a bit off topic. I'm new, well back to collecting models (since I sold my Hornby layout in 1976) and I'm amazed at the great and detailed locos available out there. I'm looking to get a streamlined S class steam and done a bit of research, but the prices, and presumably quality, varies greatly. Could someone comment on the difference between, say, the Steam Era Models metal kit at $595 and the BGM version at $1,950. The latter is fully built, so I would expect it to be a little more expensive but that's a huge difference. Then there's an unstreamlined BGM version on Ebay for $3,245, second hand, yet a new X class BGM is $1,950. So all a bit confusing. I guess what I really want to know is, which are the best?
welcome back to the greatest hobby!
As far as I know, there are no VR S-class steamers available ready-to-run commercially. Steam Era and BGM provide brass and whitemetal kits. The BGM version at $1950 would be a kit that has been made by someone.
There is a great deal of effort in making a kit. Probably 50 to 80 hours depending on the complexity of the kit. With that in mind, $595 going to $1950 is a pretty reasonable deal. (If a plumber or a sparky spent 50-80 hours doing something at your home, how much would you be paying???)
The unstreamlined S on e-bay is (in my opinion....) way overpriced.
Steam Era have a very good reputation for kits though I have never built any of their Brass/whitemetal kits. A brass and whitemetal locomotive kit is certainly not for the beginner. But they are doable once the modeller has built up some experience.
If you can buy a completed kit, I'd recommend that you get it. Look at the build carefully and observe it running through turnouts and around curves.... not just on a straight test track.
Good luck!
Sorry if this is a bit off topic. I'm new, well back to collecting models (since I sold my Hornby layout in 1976) and I'm amazed at the great and detailed locos available out there. I'm looking to get a streamlined S class steam and done a bit of research, but the prices, and presumably quality, varies greatly. Could someone comment on the difference between, say, the Steam Era Models metal kit at $595 and the BGM version at $1,950. The latter is fully built, so I would expect it to be a little more expensive but that's a huge difference. Then there's an unstreamlined BGM version on Ebay for $3,245, second hand, yet a new X class BGM is $1,950. So all a bit confusing. I guess what I really want to know is, which are the best?
welcome back to the greatest hobby!
As far as I know, there are no VR S-class steamers available ready-to-run commercially. Steam Era and BGM provide brass and whitemetal kits. The BGM version at $1950 would be a kit that has been made by someone.
There is a great deal of effort in making a kit. Probably 50 to 80 hours depending on the complexity of the kit. With that in mind, $595 going to $1950 is a pretty reasonable deal. (If a plumber or a sparky spent 50-80 hours doing something at your home, how much would you be paying???)
The unstreamlined S on e-bay is (in my opinion....) way overpriced.
Steam Era have a very good reputation for kits though I have never built any of their Brass/whitemetal kits. A brass and whitemetal locomotive kit is certainly not for the beginner. But they are doable once the modeller has built up some experience.
If you can buy a completed kit, I'd recommend that you get it. Look at the build carefully and observe it running through turnouts and around curves.... not just on a straight test track.
Good luck!
Subscribers: 3333, Akaie, Bigwato, Bob K, Captain Underpants, comtrain, Cubologist, davesvline, Draffa, drgwsd50, F6310, GabiCseh, GetOffTheTrack, graham, gunzel42, hepkat63, IanB75, james13, jmcdon, justdun, lachyb, lkernan, markthetrainspotter, mattrawls, Moses Wong, MRHD66, Nijok, NSW3802, NSWGRules, Peter_Irving_4472, Railfanman, rainynight65, SAR523, Shazam75, smmt01, southskies, speedemon08, SziaOda00, The Red Rattler Newcastle, TheMeddlingMonk, thrillhouse, Toad Montgomery, trawny, Tuckly69, Wee_pierre, yesbenno, Z1948