Partial privatisation studies included in DB restructuring
The Next Federal Election and Passenger and Freight Rail
Transport and Logistics symposium to gauge railway link
Rail gets another CRC. Third time lucky?
Chinese high speed rail should confine the XPT to history
Hendy heads to NR
Urban rail news in brief - July 2015
Inland rail a trifecta for Toowoomba region: mayor
HS Rail is back in the spotlight in Australia because of lack of corridor protection for trains that could run between Melbourne-Sydney or Sydney-Brisbane in just under or over three hours respectively.
It’s undoubtedly an urgent talking point in 2017. As it was in 1987, or earlier. No-one does the urgency of nation building projects quite like Australia! However as the consequences of inaction over publicly useful transport infrastructure becomes more painfully apparent in the major cities, the discussions remain guided by interests from all perspectives, for or against, that ignore two fundamental considerations.
There is zero analysis of door-to-door trip times, as in the real-life performance of existing and proposed transport solutions, and similarly, no recognition of the mobility or immobility of the assets that underpin rail, road and airline activity.
Yet both factors will cause the making or breaking of transport projects that depend on attracting enough punters paying the right prices to survive, notwithstanding the very significant but hard to realistically model side benefits of increased general economic activity arising from better people moving services of any form.
Take the Sydney-Canberra situation. The increasingly inadequate motorway between both cities is pounded by thousands of daily users for whom air travel offers a slower journey time from their starting points between typically an hour or two away from the airports at either end of what in theory can be flown in 30 minutes, and is generally scheduled at just under one hour.
A high speed rail service from say Civic in Canberra to Central (or nearby) in Sydney could also readily connect those locations in just under an hour, using new rail lines that avoid the historic, scenic, and semi-paralytic routing that currently renders the trip around four hours in duration, and often gets snared up by congestion from freight trains and suburban services.
While the road trip can take more than the often claimed three hours 30 minutes, it gets a traveller from a residential starting point to a decentralised campus, or technology park, or business location as much as two hours sooner than would be the case fighting cross town traffic to Sydney Airport, stuffing around in the terminal and of course the time wasting airline lounge at either or both ends.
It doesn’t matter how fast the train might be between Kingston (Canberra) and Central (Sydney) if your journey is to Macquarie University or North Ryde or Parramatta.
A high speed rail service between Canberra and Sydney, even if it departed every ten minutes, and travelled at the speed of light, wouldn’t be competitive in terms of time with a door to door journey.
There is a serious lack of published research into the real nature of Sydney-Canberra road trips. Those who want to boost the notion of a Sydney-Canberra high speed train run away from the risk of not having enough customers for high frequency departures. And if you make anyone wait up to two hours for such a train, you are, to be blunt, a fool. The aircraft that fly the route often come with less than 100 seats (and very uncomfortable ones too), and their operating economics do not require filling the 600-800 or more seats that are common on successful European and Asian high speed rail services.
However to make real money, for their owners, rather than society as a whole, high speed trains need to rack up the same levels of utilisation as airliners.
This article first appeared on blogs.crikey.com.au
About this website
Railpage version 3.10.0.0037
All logos and trademarks in this site are property of their respective owner. The comments are property of their posters, all the rest is © 2003-2017 Interactive Omnimedia Pty Ltd.
You can syndicate our news using one of the RSS feeds.