1910 Heathcote Junction accident

 
  VRees Beginner

G'day I'm trying to find any images or better information on this and also the Kurkurac Creek bridge accident too. I've found a few posts on it but my image searches have come up with nothing.

Cheers!

Sponsored advertisement

  WimbledonW Chief Train Controller

Location: Sydney
G'day I'm trying to find any images or better information on this and also the Kurkurac Creek bridge accident too. I've found a few posts on it but my image searches have come up with nothing.

Cheers!


The National Library "Trove" program locates many newspaper articles about a runaway plus derailment accident on Saturday 19  November 1910 at Heathcote Junction a little after midnight. There was apparently a brake failure due to a leaking pipe.

The Westinghouse brake was disconnected and replaced by application of hand brakes on some of the wagons. Hand brake levers were located on only one side of the wagons, so not all were applied. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/10478870

The train passed the Distant and Home signals and ran into the deadend at the junction. The driver, James Ryan, 43, was killed when the loco tipped over on its side.

The locomotive was a DD class 674. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/10478870

The Junction was actually called Kilmore Junction. See https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/10478867

The inquest found that no one was to blame. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/142935276

Driver Ryan was scalded to death and leaves a widow and six children. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/216871229

John Henry Williams was cleaner and acting fireman on the crashed train. C B Farlane was the guard. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/26296590 The guards van stayed on the rails upright.

Lewis Malcolm was the stationmaster (signalman) at Kilmore Junction.

The accident blocked the adjacent Down Main line, and single line working was implemented via the Up Main Line. Breakdown trains and their steam cranes were summoned from Spencer Street and Seymour. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/53198825

The inquest was held in Bendigo. Dr. Cole was coroner.

Trove mentions Kurkurac as  an army training camp.
  hbedriver Assistant Commissioner

I recall references to the Kurkuruc Creek bridge collapsing beneath a Dd way back when. A Gavan-Duffy manuscript circa 1935 mentions the event, as he describes a trip to Bendigo from Wallan on an AEC. I think the crew died, but passengers survived. Thankfully such bridge collapse events were rare.

The drivers union puts out “Loco Lines”, which several issues back reported the HJ incident. Really terrible crew conditions, driver unfamiliar with the track, two nights away from home. Cannot remember which issue, but I believe it was within the last 5 years. Do your own Google
  WimbledonW Chief Train Controller

Location: Sydney
For Railway accidents in Victoria#Kurkuruc Creek 1907

See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Railway_accidents_in_Victoria#Kurkuruc_Creek,_1907

For photo of crash see https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/175797874
  historian Deputy Commissioner

Dr Cole the coroner again. The railway's friend.

From the reports, the initial cause was the 'total' failure of the Westinghouse brake. This led to the second cause: the train was not failed; someone - the railways or the crew - decided to bring it home on the handbrakes. Which led to the third cause: mismanagement of the braking after leaving Leslie. The driver could scarcely be blamed for this - his experience in running trains using handbrakes only on steep grades was likely to be limited if it existed at all.

With regard to the Coroner's findings - it's noteworthy that the VR had a number of accidents causing death due to brake 'failures' in this period. Beaufort. Sunshine. Kilmore Junction.
  VRees Beginner

G'day I'm trying to find any images or better information on this and also the Kurkurac Creek bridge accident too. I've found a few posts on it but my image searches have come up with nothing.

Cheers!


The National Library "Trove" program locates many newspaper articles about a runaway plus derailment accident on Saturday 19  November 1910 at Heathcote Junction a little after midnight. There was apparently a brake failure due to a leaking pipe.

The Westinghouse brake was disconnected and replaced by application of hand brakes on some of the wagons. Hand brake levers were located on only one side of the wagons, so not all were applied. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/10478870

The train passed the Distant and Home signals and ran into the deadend at the junction. The driver, James Ryan, 43, was killed when the loco tipped over on its side.

The locomotive was a DD class 674. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/10478870

The Junction was actually called Kilmore Junction. See https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/10478867

The inquest found that no one was to blame. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/142935276

Driver Ryan was scalded to death and leaves a widow and six children. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/216871229

John Henry Williams was cleaner and acting fireman on the crashed train. C B Farlane was the guard. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/26296590 The guards van stayed on the rails upright.

Lewis Malcolm was the stationmaster (signalman) at Kilmore Junction.

The accident blocked the adjacent Down Main line, and single line working was implemented via the Up Main Line. Breakdown trains and their steam cranes were summoned from Spencer Street and Seymour. https://trove.nla.gov.au/newspaper/article/53198825

The inquest was held in Bendigo. Dr. Cole was coroner.

Trove mentions Kurkurac as  an army training camp.
WimbledonW
Thanks for that! I've learned that there is a section on the area in one of the ARHS bulletins which should contain the image(s) I'm looking after to go with all those facts.
  VRees Beginner

I recall references to the Kurkuruc Creek bridge collapsing beneath a Dd way back when. A Gavan-Duffy manuscript circa 1935 mentions the event, as he describes a trip to Bendigo from Wallan on an AEC. I think the crew died, but passengers survived. Thankfully such bridge collapse events were rare.

The drivers union puts out “Loco Lines”, which several issues back reported the HJ incident. Really terrible crew conditions, driver unfamiliar with the track, two nights away from home. Cannot remember which issue, but I believe it was within the last 5 years. Do your own Google
hbedriver


Yes from the images of Kurkuruc it looks as if the crew wouldn't have had much of a chance nose diving the way it did.Thanks for the info mate, I'll seek it out somehow.
  VRees Beginner

Dr Cole the coroner again. The railway's friend.

From the reports, the initial cause was the 'total' failure of the Westinghouse brake. This led to the second cause: the train was not failed; someone - the railways or the crew - decided to bring it home on the handbrakes. Which led to the third cause: mismanagement of the braking after leaving Leslie. The driver could scarcely be blamed for this - his experience in running trains using handbrakes only on steep grades was likely to be limited if it existed at all.

With regard to the Coroner's findings - it's noteworthy that the VR had a number of accidents causing death due to brake 'failures' in this period. Beaufort. Sunshine. Kilmore Junction.
historian
Absolutely. It must have been an awful situation to be in. I'm trying to gather all the info on these accidents as a bit of a supplement for my dad who likes the old days and now has Parkinsons and dementia. Every bit helps!

Sponsored advertisement

Subscribers: WimbledonW

Display from:   

Quick Reply

We've disabled Quick Reply for this thread as it was last updated more than six months ago.